Commonly when schedules are offered, he or she is given with 24 hours of the week you to definitely does perhaps not meets with that big date since it for the real history. One such analogy happens in Harry Potter therefore the Prisoner from Azkaban when Sybill Trelawney makes reference to sixteen October while the Monday, regardless of if sixteen October 1993 is actually a monday.
There are also contradictions during the books here. Including, in the Harry Potter and Goblet out-of Fire, how to meet Baoding ladies one another step one September and you may dos September are provided because Mondays and you may, into the Harry Potter additionally the Prisoner from Azkaban, Buckbeak’s trial is decided for the 20 April, but mindful parsing of one’s text message demonstrates that it may have occurred no later on than just February.
Along with, into the Harry Potter and also the Cup of Flames they do say that Winners was basically chosen for the Monday 31 October, however, 29 October try a monday from inside the 1994.
From inside the a bankruptcy proceeding from Quidditch From the Years, it is said your first Quidditch World Glass occured in the 1473. If for example the tournament are stored all the couple of years, so it disputes on report inside Goblet out of Fire that 1994 World Cup are the fresh 422nd. In the event that Quidditch From the Many years is useful, the fresh 422nd Quidditch Business Mug create in fact fall in the entire year 3161, but if Cup from Fire is good, the original Community Glass got held when you look at the 306.
Historical dilemmas [ ]
While the series, according to timeline produced by the Chamber regarding Treasures reference, is determined regarding 1990s, the fresh new series often appears like it is devote new late 1990s to help you mid-2000s, approximately concurrent for the publication of the guides. Inside Harry Potter therefore the 1 / 2 of-Blood Prince, Cornelius Fudge spends a masculine pronoun to refer to the “predecessor” of one’s Best Minister of one’s Uk. With respect to the above schedule, this will occur in the summertime regarding 1996, in the event the Perfect Minister are John Biggest, whoever instantaneous predecessor try a female (is why basic ending up in Fudge, the book says the new election, however, Significant was not very first select and simply grabbed more than just after Thatcher retired.
You’ll be able to, yet not unrealistic, that Fudge might be speaking about a very faraway predecessor, while the Thatcher grabbed place of work ahead of Fudge supposedly turned into Minister getting Wonders. (In the event you can imagine a scenario where Fudge was delegated because of the Minister to own Wonders to generally meet towards Primary Minister while he, Fudge, was in a smaller sized office.) Likewise, new character and you will reputation for the top Minister portrayed seems to much more closely fits that of Tony Blair than simply out of John Big. A blog post from the Every day Mail cards you to Rowling was romantic toward next-Chancellor of your Exchequer Gordon Brown (have a tendency to viewed as a competitor so you’re able to Blair’s frontrunners of your Labour Class, just who succeeded your and you can became Finest Minister), which she could have been attempting to reveal Blair’s terrible front. Whether your instructions was basically place in connect that have book day out-of Philosopher’s Stone, next it enjoy would take place in 2002 (once Blair turned into Primary Minister).
Although not, it was later on reported that 22 November was a monday, that it was in 1994
The same problem pertains to Nicolas Flamel, who was said as being 665 at the time of brand new basic guide, however, Nicolas Flamel is a real historic figure and would not have reached you to definitely ages up until 1996, within the time the original book try typed. This new rebuttal because of it is the fact that the time the fresh “real” Nicolas Flamel came into this world does not keep in touch with this new Nicolas Flamel out of Harry Potter.
A separate disease can be found away from Rubeus Hagrid’s period given that Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It is created from the collection you to definitely Hagrid obtained one to position contained in this a couple of years from their expulsion from college in 1942. But in one to scene of Harry Potter as well as the Goblet out of Flames, Molly Weasley reminisces from the Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper apparently convergence that have Molly’s ages in school, it looks unrealistic you to definitely she remembers a past gamekeeper. However, it will be possible one Hagrid don’t become a beneficial gamekeeper immediately just after are expelled, but alternatively started while the Ogg’s assistant. It is probable given that when Harry thinks which he commonly become expelled having flying for the broomstick in the place of consent within his first 12 months, the guy wonders when the however be permitted to stick to because Hagrid’s secretary.